The Indianapolis Colts’ Quarterback Dilemma

The Indianapolis Colts are facing a crucial decision this offseason regarding their quarterback position. With the 2025 season ending early for Daniel Jones due to a torn right Achilles tendon, the team is now looking at options to fill the void. This situation has sparked discussions about potential free agents who could step in as backups or even take over the starting role.

Potential Free Agents to Target

As the Colts consider their next steps, several veteran quarterbacks are being mentioned as possible targets. Here are three names that could be on their radar:

Russell Wilson

Russell Wilson, a former third-round pick by the Seattle Seahawks, has had a storied career but has faced challenges in recent years. After playing for three teams in four seasons, he was benched by the New York Giants this past year. His days of securing guaranteed starting jobs in free agency may be over, but his experience and leadership could still make him an attractive option.

If the Colts decide to bring in a veteran backup, Wilson could provide valuable mentorship during training camp. His ability to maximize the final years of his career under head coach Frank Reich might be a key factor in the decision. Additionally, his presence could serve as a strong competition for Riley Leonard, the team’s young quarterback.

Marcus Mariota

Marcus Mariota has been linked to the Colts multiple times in the past. Although the team opted for Matt Ryan in 2022, Mariota has shown that he can still perform effectively. In the 2025 season, he delivered a standout performance against the Denver Broncos, throwing for 294 yards and two touchdowns. While the team lost the game, his performance highlighted his potential.

Mariota’s ability to run and his experience with play-action formations could be beneficial for the Colts. At this stage of his career, he seems to have adapted well to being a full-time backup, making him a viable option if the team is looking for a reliable second-string quarterback.

Jimmy Garoppolo

Jimmy Garoppolo, another name associated with the Colts in the past, is set to hit free agency. Known for his accuracy and ability to read defenses, Garoppolo has played for several teams, including the New England Patriots, San Francisco 49ers, and Las Vegas Raiders. Recently, he served as Matthew Stafford’s backup on the Los Angeles Rams.

Garoppolo has come to terms with being a backup in the NFL, which makes him a practical choice for the Colts. If he leaves the Rams, it’s likely that the team would be interested in his services. His skill set closely resembles that of Daniel Jones, making him a strong candidate to step in if Jones is unable to play all 17 games.

Conclusion

With the Colts needing to address their quarterback situation, the decision to re-sign Daniel Jones or explore other options will be critical. The team’s need for a veteran backup is clear, and the potential targets discussed above could provide the necessary depth and experience. Whether they choose to bring in a seasoned player like Russell Wilson, Marcus Mariota, or Jimmy Garoppolo, the decision will shape the team’s future success.