The Chicago Cubs’ Offseason Dilemma

The Chicago Cubs have had a busy offseason, but it still feels incomplete. After missing out on Tatsuya Imai, the team is looking to make more moves before spring training begins in February. One of the names that has surfaced in recent discussions is Bo Bichette, a free-agent infielder who has caught the attention of the North Siders.

According to reports from the New York Post’s Jon Heyman, the Cubs are among several teams interested in Bichette. While the Cubs have been loosely connected to the veteran second baseman in the past, this is the first time there has been a direct link. However, there seems to be only one scenario where such a move would make sense.

Potential Scenarios for the Cubs

One possible scenario involves the Cubs exploring trade options for second baseman Nico Hoerner. Although the team isn’t actively shopping Hoerner this winter, his contract status makes him an attractive target for other teams. Recently, the San Francisco Giants have emerged as a potential suitor for Hoerner.

Jed Hoyer and his staff like to explore multiple scenarios during the offseason. It’s possible they’ve considered a situation where Hoerner is traded, and the Cubs then pivot to sign Bichette to replace him at second base. While this scenario might not be highly likely, it highlights the various paths the Cubs could take this offseason.

However, it’s important to note that this scenario might not significantly improve the Cubs’ offense compared to their performance in the 2025 season. Without a clear need for a second baseman, it’s hard to imagine the Cubs making a move for Bichette unless they’re planning a major shift in their lineup.

Bichette and the Third Base Dilemma

Bichette has never played third base at the major league level, and the Cubs have generally avoided long-term deals. This makes it even less likely that they would pursue Bichette unless they were willing to make a significant exception. Additionally, the Cubs’ run-prevention model doesn’t align with Bichette’s skill set, which further complicates the possibility of a trade.

Another factor influencing Bichette’s free agency is the Toronto Blue Jays’ recent acquisition of Kazuma Okamoto. A return to Toronto was once seen as a strong possibility for Bichette, but that may no longer be the case.

The Impact of Other Free-Agent Moves

If the Blue Jays sign Kyle Tucker, it could create a ripple effect that impacts Bichette’s market. This could potentially tie Bichette’s free agency to the Cubs’ interest in Alex Bregman. The Boston Red Sox have also been linked to Bichette, and if they sign him, it could increase the Cubs’ chances of landing Bregman.

As the offseason progresses, the Cubs need to move beyond just mapping out scenarios and start taking action. Their patience has already cost them some opportunities, and there’s a real risk of entering the 2026 season with a weaker roster than the one they had in 2025.

What’s Next for the Cubs?

With so many variables at play, the Cubs must decide how to proceed. Whether they pursue Bichette, look for other options, or focus on internal development, the next few weeks will be crucial in shaping the team’s future. The pressure is mounting, and the time for speculation is running out.